1. Beautiful Homes
2. tshirt!
3. gift
3. Beer

Menu

NOTE: Entering your credit card only reserves your order. Payment is to be completed at the store.

Click here to View our Menu and Order Online for pickup at the College Avenue store ONLY.

Click here for our PRINTABLE sandwich menu.

Sandwiches • Soups & Salads • Entrees • Breads & Bagels • Beverages • Desserts & Pastries • Ice Cream

Sandwiches
Collegetown Bagels has a full range of inspired sandwiches, each one an experience in itself. Choose from over 100 combinations of bagel, deli, or specialty sandwiches and wraps. Sandwiches are served on our own freshly made Ithaca Bakery breads. Vegan, vegetarian and gluten free options are available.

Soups & Salads
Our soups and salads change every day. From hearty chilis, to chowders, bisques, and even chilled soups in the summer, there's a soup for everyone. Check the website or Facebook to find out today's soup selections. Green salads, Caesar, and a rotating menu of options, the salads at CTB are fresh every day. The downtown Aurora Street and Ithaca Bakery on Route 13 locations also feature salad bars. To view the soups for today for the Collegetown Bagels stores, please visit our Facebook page. "Like" us and you'll be kept up to date on soups, specials and more!

Entrees & Meals to Go
Every day in the kitchens of Brous & Mehaffey, Chef Guy Emerson and his skilled staff draw from the wide world of cuisine to create delectable, beautiful, and diverse entrees and side dishes. Grab and go, or have an entree heated at the store. Bring home dinner for the family or for yourself. You can view the Meals to Go menu here.

Breads & Bagels
Over 1,000 dozen bagels are baked every day! Flavors include all your favorites (see below!) plus specialty options like chocolate chip, sundried tomato, apple walnut, pumpkin, rosemary salt that change monthly. Call for our current montly specials.

  • Plain
  • Sesame
  • Poppy
  • Cinnamon Raisin
  • Onion
  • Multigrain
  • Honey Wheat
  • Sesame Honey Wheat
  • Long Island Honey Wheat
  • Pumpernickel
  • Rosemary Salt
  • Spicy Italian
  • Long Island
  • Garlic
  • Salt
  • Cheddar
  • Blueberry
  • Don't forget Bialies!

All breads are made fresh by hand every day using the finest ingredients to produce honest, hearty, delicious breads. Take a loaf home, on a picnic, or pair it with one of our delicious cheese selections available at each store.

Beverages
Accompany your meal with the perfect beverage. 100% of our coffee is Fair Trade, and you can choose from espresso based drinks or drip coffee. Try one of our fresh fruit smoothies or hot or cold brewed teas. Each store also includes a full selection of popular beverages including sodas, juices, spritzers, iced teas, energy drinks and more. Beer and Wine is available at the College Avenue store.

Desserts & Pastries
Customers gaze into our pastry cases with adoring eyes and bring our cakes and pies to the best parties in town. Jumbo cookies share space with homemade shortbreads, biscotti, pistachio and ginger cookies and countless others. Cupcakes, Tiramisu, Cheesecake Brownies, Carrot Cake, Lemon or Key Lime Tartlets, Dessert Stones, Almond Crescents... The list is enormous. Come see—or better!—taste for yourself! Order ahead specialty cakes and dessert platters for your most cherished occasions.

Ice Cream
A summer treat or warm over one of our delicious pies or brownies, scooped ice cream is on the menu at our downtown Aurora Street and Collegetown locations. Ice Cream novelties and flavors by the pint are also available.